Real Life Real Crime

Woody Overton returns with another episode of True Crime Time, covering a disturbing murder aboard a cruise ship, the conviction of a former Massachusetts police detective, the heartbreaking death of a 13-year-old Baton Rouge student, and troubling findings concerning Louisiana's handling of sexual assault evidence.
The episode opens with This Day in History, revisiting the University of Idaho student murders, the conviction of Scott Peterson, the crimes of Chinese serial killer Huang Yong, the 1935 lynching of two Black teenagers in Texas, and the bombing of United Airlines Flight 629.
Woody then examines capital punishment in China, including execution by gunshot, lethal injection, and the country's controversial use of mobile execution vehicles. Drawing comparisons to Louisiana's history of traveling electric-chair executions, he discusses how different countries have administered the death penalty.
In the episode's first major case, a passenger aboard the MSC Seascape is accused of beating and strangling a woman during a cruise in international waters. Federal investigators describe surveillance footage, statements from the accused, and the discovery of the victim inside the couple's cabin.
Next, in F'd-Up Professionals, Woody discusses the federal murder conviction of former Massachusetts police detective Matthew Farwell in the death of Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child. Prosecutors argued that Farwell groomed Birchmore beginning in her teenage years and later staged her death to resemble a suicide. Woody examines the abuse of authority and the importance of challenging questionable death investigations.
The episode also covers a violent confrontation among football fans outside Levi's Stadium in California and the arrest of an airline passenger accused of making a bomb threat aboard a flight arriving in New Orleans.
Closer to home, Woody discusses the death of 13-year-old Joshua Bonilla Ortega, a Westdale Middle School student found in a wooded area near Gardere in Baton Rouge. Authorities say Ortega was shot while three teenagers were handling a handgun and taking photographs. Two other juveniles were arrested after allegedly leaving the scene without seeking help.
Finally, Woody turns to a Louisiana legislative audit revealing serious shortcomings in the collection, submission, and tracking of sexual assault evidence kits. He explains the importance of preserving forensic evidence, maintaining chain of custody, and ensuring survivors can monitor the progress of their cases.
Drawing on his years as a homicide detective, Woody shares firsthand experiences with evidence collection and the Louisiana State Police Crime Lab while emphasizing accountability to victims and their families.
Show Notes
This Day in History — November 12
2022: Woody revisits the murders of University of Idaho students Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin, and the prosecution of Bryan Kohberger.
1934: Charles Manson is born in Cincinnati, Ohio.
2004: Scott Peterson is convicted of murdering his pregnant wife, Laci Peterson, and their unborn son, Conner.
2003: Chinese serial killer Huang Yong is arrested after murdering 17 teenage boys.
1935: Ernest Collins and Benny Mitchell, two Black teenagers, are lynched by a white mob in Colorado County, Texas.
1955: Investigators make progress in the United Airlines Flight 629 bombing case involving Jack Gilbert Graham.
Capital Punishment in China
Woody examines China's death penalty system and the offenses for which capital punishment may be imposed.
Discussion of executions by gunshot and lethal injection.
The role of the Supreme People's Court in reviewing death sentences.
Historical accounts of execution procedures and allegations involving organ harvesting.
A recorded segment describes China's mobile lethal-injection execution vehicles.
Woody compares these practices with Louisiana's historical use of a traveling electric chair.
Story 1 — Murder Charge Following Death Aboard MSC Seascape
Jason Leon Watford, 48, is charged with murder following a woman's death aboard the MSC Seascape.
Federal investigators allege Watford beat and strangled the woman during an argument in their cabin.
Surveillance footage and statements from ship employees become important parts of the investigation.
A housekeeper discovers the woman motionless and reports the situation to ship personnel.
The cruise ship returns to Galveston, Texas, where FBI investigators board the vessel.
Watford's statements and the other evidence are described in a federal criminal complaint. The charge remains an allegation unless proven in court.
F'd-Up Professionals — Matthew Farwell Convicted in Sandra Birchmore Murder
Former Stoughton, Massachusetts, police detective Matthew Farwell is convicted in federal court of murdering Sandra Birchmore and causing the death of her unborn child.
Prosecutors presented evidence of a sexual relationship beginning when Birchmore was a minor and involved in a police youth program.
Birchmore was found dead in her apartment in February 2021.
Her death was initially classified as suicide before investigators reopened the case.
Federal investigators uncovered approximately 40,000 text messages between Birchmore and Farwell.
Farwell's defense maintained that Birchmore died by suicide.
Woody discusses the abuse of authority, investigative accountability, and the devastating loss experienced by Birchmore's family.
Story 3 — Violence Among NFL Fans at Levi's Stadium
Viral footage shows a large fight involving football fans outside Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, California.
Reports describe arrests and stadium ejections following multiple disturbances.
Woody questions why fans risk their safety and freedom over sporting events.
He discusses the growing visibility of public violence through social media.
Story 4 — Airline Passenger Accused of Bomb Threat Near New Orleans
A 34-year-old passenger is arrested following an alleged bomb threat aboard an aircraft.
The flight lands safely at Louis Armstrong New Orleans International Airport.
No passenger injuries are reported.
The suspect faces charges involving communicating false information and terrorizing.
Woody discusses the serious consequences of threats involving aircraft and airports.
Story 5 — Baton Rouge Teen Killed During Incident Involving Handgun
Thirteen-year-old Joshua Bonilla Ortega is found dead in a wooded area near Gardere Lane.
Investigators say three juveniles were handling a handgun and taking photographs when Ortega was shot.
Two other 13-year-olds allegedly left the scene without seeking assistance.
Both juveniles are arrested, with additional charges including negligent homicide and obstruction of justice.
Ortega attended Westdale Middle School and was remembered by family members for his love of soccer.
Woody emphasizes firearm safety education, secure gun storage, and the responsibility to seek immediate help during an emergency.
Final Story — Louisiana Sexual Assault Kit Tracking Audit
A Louisiana legislative audit identifies problems with the handling and submission of sexual assault evidence kits.
The state's tracking system, launched in 2024, allows survivors to check the status of their evidence.
The audit finds that 17.9% of kits collected during the reviewed period were not submitted within the required timeframe.
More than 25% were not collected from medical facilities within the statutory deadline.
Thirty agencies had not enrolled in the tracking system, and 60 kits were missing from it.
Woody explains evidence collection, refrigeration, documentation, chain of custody, and crime lab submissions from his detective experience.
He discusses how delays and missing documentation can affect prosecutions and undermine victims' confidence in the justice system.
Content Warning: This episode discusses murder, sexual assault, child exploitation, suicide-related evidence, racial violence, executions, and the death of a child. Listener discretion is advised.
Host: Woody Overton
Podcast: Real Life Real Crime — True Crime Time
#RealLifeRealCrime #TrueCrimeTime #WoodyOverton #SandraBirchmore #MatthewFarwell #JoshuaBonillaOrtega #LouisianaTrueCrime #SexualAssaultEvidence #TrueCrimeNews

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

On this Veterans Day edition of True Crime Time, Woody Overton honors the men and women who have served in the United States military while examining a darker side of American history: notorious criminals who once wore the uniform.
A veteran himself, Woody opens with a personal tribute to those who served, including his father, friends, and fellow service members. He reflects on the discipline, sacrifice, and lifelong impact of military service before turning to cases involving former military personnel who later committed horrific crimes.
Woody revisits the military backgrounds of Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh, Green River Killer Gary Ridgway, Jeffrey Dahmer, BTK killer Dennis Rader, and Son of Sam killer David Berkowitz.
He also examines violence directed against veterans, including the 1946 assault on Black World War II veteran Isaac Woodard and the deadly 1919 Centralia conflict on Armistice Day.
The episode's central focus is the April 19, 1995, Oklahoma City bombing, which killed 168 people, including 19 children. Woody walks listeners through Timothy McVeigh's military service, radicalization, the bombing itself, and the extraordinary FBI investigation that led to his capture and conviction.
Drawing from FBI accounts and his own experience as a detective, Woody examines how investigators traced the rented truck, identified McVeigh, and uncovered the involvement of Terry Nichols and Michael Fortier.
Woody then explores McVeigh's 2001 execution, the unusual arrangements that allowed survivors and victims' families to witness it, and what ultimately happened to the other men involved in the bombing.
The discussion leads to an examination of the Federal Witness Security Program, commonly known as witness protection or WITSEC. Woody discusses how cooperating witnesses receive new identities, relocate, and attempt to build new lives while remaining separated from their former criminal associations.
Throughout the episode, Woody shares personal memories of military service, the Oklahoma City bombing, and his desire to return to the military following September 11, 2001.
He closes by recognizing the sacrifices of veterans, including those living with service-related disabilities, and expressing gratitude for everyone who has served.
Show Notes
Veterans Day — Honoring Those Who Served
Woody reflects on his military service and the veterans in his family.
The difference between Veterans Day and Memorial Day.
How military experience can shape discipline, responsibility, and lifelong relationships.
Woody shares his belief in the value of military service and honors veterans across generations.
This Day in History — Belle Gunness
Born November 11, 1859, Belle Gunness became one of America's most notorious suspected serial killers.
Multiple suspicious deaths, disappearances, and fires surrounded her life.
Investigators discovered numerous human remains on her Indiana property.
Whether Gunness herself died in the farmhouse fire remains disputed.
Notorious Criminals Who Served in the Military
Timothy McVeigh: Decorated U.S. Army veteran responsible for the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing.
Gary Ridgway: The Green River Killer served in the U.S. Navy during the Vietnam era.
Jeffrey Dahmer: Served in the U.S. Army and was stationed in West Germany.
Dennis Rader: The BTK killer served in the U.S. Air Force.
David Berkowitz: The Son of Sam killer previously served in the U.S. Army.
Crimes Against Veterans
The history of racist violence targeting Black veterans returning from military service.
The 1946 assault on Isaac Woodard, a Black World War II veteran who was permanently blinded by police.
The 1919 Centralia conflict in Washington, where violence involving American Legion members and Industrial Workers of the World members resulted in multiple deaths.
Woody reflects on military brotherhood and the importance of recognizing every veteran's service.
Featured Case — The Oklahoma City Bombing
On April 19, 1995, Timothy McVeigh detonated a truck bomb outside the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building.
The explosion killed 168 people, including 19 children, and injured hundreds more.
Investigators traced vehicle components recovered from the bombing scene to identify the rented truck.
McVeigh was already in custody following a traffic stop approximately 90 minutes after the attack.
Evidence connected McVeigh to the bombing and revealed the involvement of Terry Nichols and Michael Fortier.
Woody discusses McVeigh's military background, anti-government extremism, and the influence of Ruby Ridge and Waco.
The FBI conducted tens of thousands of interviews and followed thousands of leads.
Timothy McVeigh's Execution
McVeigh was convicted in 1997 and executed by lethal injection on June 11, 2001.
He declined to deliver spoken final words and instead provided the poem Invictus as his final statement.
His final meal consisted of mint chocolate chip ice cream.
Selected victims' relatives and survivors witnessed the execution in person.
Additional survivors and family members watched through a special closed-circuit television broadcast in Oklahoma City.
Woody reflects on the families' search for justice and closure.
What Happened to Terry Nichols and Michael Fortier?
Terry Nichols was convicted for his involvement in the bombing and received multiple life sentences.
Nichols remains incarcerated at the federal supermax prison in Florence, Colorado.
Woody discusses Nichols' prison conditions and reported efforts to sell artwork, including restitution obligations.
Michael Fortier cooperated with federal prosecutors and testified against McVeigh and Nichols.
Fortier served a reduced prison sentence and was released in 2006.
He subsequently entered the Federal Witness Security Program.
Inside the Federal Witness Protection Program
How the U.S. Marshals Service administers WITSEC.
Screening and eligibility considerations for cooperating witnesses.
The process of relocating participants and establishing new identities.
Restrictions on contact with former associates and previous social networks.
Temporary financial assistance and the expectation of eventual self-sufficiency.
Special protections for incarcerated witnesses.
The consequences of violating program rules or committing additional crimes.
Woody shares his perspective on the challenges of protecting witnesses with serious criminal histories.
Closing Tribute — Veterans and Their Families
Woody recalls considering reenlisting after the September 11 terrorist attacks.
He discusses Pat Tillman's decision to leave professional football for military service.
Acknowledgment of disabled veterans and the sacrifices made by service members and their families.
A final Veterans Day message of appreciation and respect.
Content Warning: This episode discusses terrorism, mass murder, child deaths, executions, racial violence, and serial killings. Listener discretion is advised.
Host: Woody Overton
Podcast: Real Life Real Crime — True Crime Time
#RealLifeRealCrime #TrueCrimeTime #WoodyOverton #VeteransDay #OklahomaCityBombing #TimothyMcVeigh #TerryNichols #WitnessProtection #TrueCrimeHistory

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

This Day in History — November 10
2003: The case of Mary Lynn Witherspoon, who was murdered after being stalked by Edmonds Tennant.
1998: Eight-year-old Maddie Clifton's body is discovered inside the home of her teenage neighbor, Josh Phillips, in Jacksonville, Florida.
2009: John Allen Muhammad, one of the perpetrators of the 2002 D.C. sniper attacks, is executed in Virginia.
1985: A hunter discovers a barrel containing human remains in New Hampshire, an early discovery in the Bear Brook murders investigation.
2008: Serial killer Arthur Shawcross dies in prison.
1951: Birth of William Henry Hance, a convicted serial killer executed in Georgia in 1994.
1938: Kristallnacht, the Nazi-organized campaign of antisemitic violence, concludes.
Story 1 — Two Spokane County Deputies Killed in Domestic Violence Response
Deputies Mason Acheson and Parker Perry respond to a November 3 domestic violence emergency near Spangle, Washington.
Deputies attempting to reach potential victims inside a home come under gunfire.
Acheson dies from his injuries, while Perry remains on life support for organ donation before his death.
Investigators identify the gunman as Ryan Larson, who dies from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
Larson's mother and sister are also found dead inside the residence.
Woody honors the deputies' military service, law enforcement careers, and surviving families.
Story 2 — Russell Brand Sentencing Report
Woody plays a news segment reporting that British actor and comedian Russell Brand has received a 10½-year prison sentence.
The report describes convictions involving rape and sexual assault.
Additional allegations are described as remaining under investigation.
Woody discusses celebrity, abuse of power, and accountability.
Story 3 — Dallas Public Defender's Office Investigator Charged With Wife's Murder
Jimmy Spurger Jr., chief investigator for the Dallas County Public Defender's Office, is charged with first-degree murder.
His wife, Maria Teresa Spurger, is found dead in their downtown Dallas apartment on November 6.
Investigators describe a barricaded doorway, stab wounds, and evidence recovered at the scene.
Spurger is discovered injured inside the apartment and taken for medical treatment.
The couple had been married for approximately 35 years, and Spurger had recently filed for divorce.
Woody discusses the reported evidence and the contrast between Spurger's investigative career and the criminal charge he now faces.
Family Matters — Florida Grandmother Accused of Stealing Halloween Decoration
Tanya Jean Mannion is accused of taking an inflatable Halloween ghost from a neighbor's porch while caring for three grandchildren.
Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd describes the incident in a video featured during the episode.
Investigators report recovering the decoration.
Mannion faces burglary, theft, criminal mischief, and related charges.
Woody shares his appreciation for Sheriff Judd's memorable approach to communicating with the public.
Story 4 — Postal Worker Discovers Note Leading to Three Bodies in New Jersey
USPS employee Don Clemens discovers an unusual handwritten note requesting someone call 911.
Police respond to a home in Mount Holly, New Jersey, on November 6.
Three adults, described by neighbors as two brothers and a sister, are found dead inside.
The note includes two hand-drawn sad faces.
Authorities have not publicly established the cause of death or identified a suspect in the reporting discussed.
Woody examines the unusual circumstances and unanswered questions surrounding the discovery.
Story 5 — Kentucky Woman Accused of Strangling High School Football Player
Kayla Barrett, 36, is arrested following an alleged October 30 incident at a football game between Wayne County and North Laurel.
Investigators allege Barrett approached a teenage player and strangled him from behind.
The student receives medical evaluation.
Barrett faces a second-degree strangulation charge.
Woody discusses the responsibility of adults to protect young athletes and maintain safe sporting environments.
Content Warning: This episode discusses domestic violence, murder, sexual assault, violence against children, and antisemitic persecution. Listener discretion is advised.
Host: Woody Overton
Podcast: Real Life Real Crime — True Crime Time
#RealLifeRealCrime #TrueCrimeTime #WoodyOverton #SpokaneCounty #RussellBrand #DallasCrime #MaddieClifton #TrueCrimeNews

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton returns with another episode of True Crime Time, covering international violence, disturbing allegations against trusted professionals, the murder of a young woman in Brooklyn, the death of a Colorado police officer, and a troubling investigation into deaths inside a Louisiana prison.
The episode begins with This Day in History, revisiting the unsolved 1954 murder of 14-year-old Carolyn Loretta Wasilewski, Jack the Ripper's final canonical victim, Mary Jane Kelly, the John List family murders, and the Nazi violence of Kristallnacht in 1938.
In Poland, a mass shooting in Krakow's historic market square leaves six people dead and numerous others injured. Authorities are investigating the attack as suspected far-right terrorism, and investigators report finding three members of the alleged gunman's family dead at his home.
In Brooklyn, police arrest Saeed Muhassib in connection with the fatal stabbing of 28-year-old Katie Suarez while she was jogging along the waterfront. Surveillance footage and other evidence lead investigators to the suspect, who previously had a brief employment history with the NYPD.
Woody then examines a disturbing lawsuit involving former pediatric urologist Brian Sack. Families allege that intimate photographs of young patients taken during medical procedures were stored in the same personal cloud account as child sexual abuse material. Woody questions how such allegations could arise within a profession entrusted with protecting children.
In Colorado, Lakewood police officer Nick Graham is killed and three fellow officers are wounded during a shootout involving a suspect aboard a bus. Woody reflects on the sacrifices made by law enforcement officers and the support provided by neighboring agencies.
The episode also includes the arrest of a South Carolina father accused of leaving his six-year-old daughter outside a Target store overnight to hold his place in line for Pokémon cards, along with criminal allegations involving a Kansas school principal and a Mississippi man.
Finally, Woody turns to Louisiana's Elayn Hunt Correctional Center, where 36 inmate deaths have been reported during 2026. He examines the crackdown on contraband, employee arrests, staffing changes, and new leadership credited with reducing suspicious deaths.
Drawing on his own experience in law enforcement and corrections, Woody discusses accountability, public safety, and the importance of protecting people who depend on institutions for their safety.
Show Notes
This Day in History — November 9
1954: Fourteen-year-old Carolyn Loretta Wasilewski is found murdered near railroad tracks in Baltimore. Her case remains unsolved.
1888: Mary Jane Kelly, widely considered Jack the Ripper's fifth and final canonical victim, is discovered murdered in London's Whitechapel district.
1971: John List murders his wife, mother, and three children in New Jersey before disappearing for nearly 18 years.
1938: Kristallnacht begins as Nazi-organized violence targets Jewish communities, synagogues, homes, and businesses across Germany and Austria.
Story 1 — Mass Shooting in Krakow, Poland
A gunman opens fire in Krakow's historic market square on November 7.
Six people are reported dead, with numerous others injured, including police officers.
Authorities identify the attack as suspected far-right terrorism.
Investigators discover the bodies of the suspect's parents and sister at the family home.
Poland begins a period of national mourning.
Woody discusses violent extremism, radicalization, and the devastating consequences of terrorism.
Story 2 — Brooklyn Jogger Katie Suarez Fatally Stabbed
Twenty-eight-year-old Katie Suarez is attacked while jogging along a Brooklyn waterfront path.
Suarez dies several days after suffering stab wounds to her neck.
Police arrest Saeed Muhassib, 27, and charge him with murder and related offenses.
Investigators reportedly use surveillance footage and evidence of discarded items to identify the suspect.
Woody discusses the apparent randomness of the attack and the devastating loss suffered by Suarez's family.
Story 3 — Former Pediatric Doctor Accused in Disturbing Lawsuit
Former pediatric urologist Brian Sack faces criminal charges involving child sexual abuse material.
Families of 13 former patients file a lawsuit concerning photographs allegedly taken during medical examinations and surgical procedures.
The complaint alleges intimate patient images were stored in a personal cloud account containing child sexual abuse material.
Woody discusses medical trust, professional accountability, and the allegations raised by the families.
The civil allegations and pending criminal charges have not been established as findings of guilt.
Story 4 — Lakewood Police Officer Killed in Colorado Bus Shooting
Lakewood officers approach a suspect aboard a bus on November 5.
Gunfire erupts, killing Officer Nick Graham and wounding three other officers.
The suspect is also killed, and a bystander is injured.
Graham is remembered for his investigative work and dedication to public service.
Neighboring law enforcement agencies assist with patrol duties while the department grieves.
Family Matters — Father Accused of Leaving Child Outside Target
John Michael Dooley is arrested in Charleston, South Carolina.
Police allege he left his six-year-old daughter outside a Target store overnight to hold his place in line for Pokémon trading cards.
Concerned customers contact authorities.
The child is found unharmed and placed in protective custody.
Dooley faces a charge of unlawful conduct toward a child.
F'd-Up Professionals — Criminal Allegations Against Individuals in Positions of Trust
A Topeka, Kansas, middle school principal, Todd Hag, is arrested on allegations involving child sex crimes.
The school district places him on administrative leave while cooperating with investigators.
In Mississippi, Edward Waltman II faces a sexual battery charge involving allegations dating to the 1980s.
Woody discusses professional responsibility and the importance of investigating allegations of abuse.
Final Story — Deaths and Reforms at Elayn Hunt Correctional Center
WBRZ reports 36 inmate deaths at the Louisiana correctional facility during 2026.
Four deaths are identified as drug overdoses, while 11 are reported as unexplained.
Officials describe a decline in suspicious deaths following new procedures and increased enforcement.
Investigators report charges against 20 current or former employees during 2026.
New leadership, staffing improvements, and contraband investigations are credited with changing conditions at the prison.
Woody draws on his corrections experience to discuss institutional accountability and the challenges of prison management.
Content Warning: This episode discusses mass shootings, murder, antisemitic violence, child sexual abuse allegations, and deaths in correctional facilities. Listener discretion is advised.
Host: Woody Overton
Podcast: Real Life Real Crime — True Crime Time
#RealLifeRealCrime #TrueCrimeTime #WoodyOverton #TrueCrimeNews #Krakow #KatieSuarez #LakewoodPolice #ElaynHunt #LouisianaTrueCrime

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton returns with an episode of True Crime Time examining one of Illinois' most controversial unsolved family murders, several Louisiana homicide cases, and renewed investigative efforts in the decades-old Jeff Davis 8 case.
The episode begins with the 1983 murders of Susan Hendricks and her three children in Bloomington, Illinois. Susan's husband, David Hendricks, was convicted of the killings, but his conviction was overturned, and he was acquitted at a retrial in 1991. Woody examines the circumstantial evidence, disputed forensic conclusions, and questions that continue to surround the unsolved murders.
Woody then turns to Louisiana, revisiting the murders of Jonathan Pizzotto and William Mitchell in Jefferson Parish, a brutal Baton Rouge homicide, a deadly home invasion in Norco, and developments in a St. Martin Parish murder investigation.
The episode's central discussion focuses on the Jeff Davis 8, also known as the Jennings 8—eight women whose deaths have remained the subject of investigations and public scrutiny for nearly two decades.
After sharing a news interview about the Jefferson Davis Parish Sheriff's Office's renewed investigative efforts, Woody examines the importance of evidence preservation, reviewing cold cases with fresh eyes, and investigating each victim's case individually before determining whether the murders are connected.
Drawing on his experience as a homicide detective, Woody offers his perspective on the investigation, discusses possible explanations for why the killings stopped, and emphasizes the importance of continuing to pursue leads.
He also addresses the challenges facing investigators and the families who have waited years for answers.
Show Notes
This Day in History — The Hendricks Family Murders
In November 1983, Susan Hendricks and her three children, Rebecca, Grace, and Benjamin, were found murdered in Bloomington, Illinois.
David Hendricks was convicted in 1984 and sentenced to four consecutive life terms.
The original prosecution relied heavily on circumstantial evidence, including estimates of the victims' time of death based on stomach contents.
The Illinois Supreme Court overturned his conviction in 1990.
Hendricks was acquitted at his 1991 retrial.
Woody examines the disputed evidence, the possibility of alternative suspects, and why the murders remain unsolved.
Louisiana Crime Cases Revisited
Jefferson Parish: Cody LaBranche's conviction for the murders of Jonathan Pizzotto and William Mitchell in Metairie.
Baton Rouge: A brutal 2016 homicide involving Oscar Perez and the killing and dismemberment of his former partner.
Norco: The 2013 murder of Mary Arico during a home invasion involving teenage suspects.
St. Martin Parish: A 2022 murder investigation involving victim Monkey Jones and an arrest warrant for Troy Borda.
Featured Discussion — The Jeff Davis 8 / Jennings 8 Investigation
The Jefferson Davis Parish Sheriff's Office provides an update on its renewed investigation into the deaths of eight women.
Investigators describe thousands of hours spent reviewing case files and evidence.
A detailed inventory identifies evidence stored in unexpected locations.
Investigators work to preserve and digitize older recordings and other materials.
The Louisiana Attorney General's Office and additional investigative resources assist with the review.
Each woman's case is being examined individually, with potential connections evaluated through the evidence.
The sheriff discusses his commitment to the victims' families and the difficulty of investigating cases nearly two decades old.
Woody's Analysis — Cold Cases, Evidence and Investigative Bias
Why reviewing original evidence with fresh eyes can reveal overlooked information.
The importance of evidence organization, preservation, and chain of custody.
The dangers of tunnel vision and confirmation bias in homicide investigations.
Why investigators should not assume all eight murders were committed by the same person without supporting evidence.
Woody shares his personal theory that the killings may have stopped because a possible perpetrator was incarcerated or died. This is his interpretation, not an established investigative finding.
The challenges of pursuing a prosecution when witnesses, evidence, and memories have been affected by the passage of time.
Why new tips and continued public attention remain important.
A Message About Unsolved Cases
Woody encourages listeners to continue sharing information about unsolved murders and emphasizes that even a seemingly minor detail may help investigators develop a lead.
Content Warning: This episode discusses the murders of children, domestic violence, sexual violence, dismemberment, and unsolved homicides. Listener discretion is advised.
Host: Woody Overton
Podcast: Real Life Real Crime — True Crime Time
#RealLifeRealCrime #TrueCrimeTime #WoodyOverton #JeffDavis8 #Jennings8 #DavidHendricks #ColdCases #LouisianaTrueCrime

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp and use my code betterhelp.com for a great deal: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com
* Check out Stio and use my code stio.com/RLRC for a great deal: https://www.stio.com
* Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code RLRC for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy