Real Life Real Crime

Woody Overton closes out September with a trip through true-crime history, beginning with John Billington, the Mayflower passenger executed for murder in 1630. He also revisits Jack the Ripper's infamous Double Event of September 30, 1888, and the Nuremberg war-crimes verdicts of 1946.
In Family Matters, a New Jersey mother is accused of hiding her missing teenage son in a crawl space, while a Memphis woman receives 30 years in prison for murdering Church's Chicken employee Anitra West following an argument over an order. Woody also covers the drowning of a three-year-old Indiana boy whose mother allegedly passed out while responsible for watching him.
Worldwide Crime takes us to Greece, where an argument over beach loungers turns fatal. Then, in F'd Up Professionals, a shooting at a North Carolina Zaxby's leaves a 19-year-old employee dead.
Finally, a significant development in Oregon: Jesse Calhoun, already facing murder charges involving five women, has been indicted on a first-degree manslaughter charge in connection with the disappearance and presumed death of a sixth woman, Elizabeth “Libby” Gibson.
Woody draws parallels to the ongoing searches for Madison Renee Allen and Stephanie Hevia, reminding listeners that every tip matters and every victim deserves answers.
Never give up. Never surrender.
True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, September 30, Jack the Ripper, Double Event, Elizabeth Stride, Catherine Eddowes, John Billington, Nuremberg Trials, Anitra West, Monaca Williams, Amy Joe Farber, Otis Johnson, Quinteris Elliott, Jesse Calhoun, Elizabeth Gibson, Libby Gibson, Oregon missing women, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Justice for Hailey, true crime
John Billington and the 1630 Plymouth murder
Jack the Ripper's Double Event
September 1946 Nuremberg verdicts
New Jersey missing-teen investigation
Anitra West's murder at Church's Chicken
Indiana child-drowning investigation
Fatal beach-lounger dispute in Greece
Zaxby's employee shooting in North Carolina
Jesse Calhoun's sixth indictment
Elizabeth “Libby” Gibson
#JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie
#JusticeForHailey and continued appeals for information

The Oregon development provides the episode's central contemporary investigative story. Calhoun faces charges connected to six women's deaths, but the newest indictment involving Libby Gibson is for first-degree manslaughter, not murder. Her remains have not been recovered. The charges remain allegations, not convictions.
Woody closes by emphasizing that an investigation does not end simply because remains have not been located—and encourages Lifers to continue submitting information in the Madison, Stephanie, Hailey and other unresolved cases. 

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton opens with updates on #JusticeForHailey, #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie, encouraging anyone with information to come forward and reminding Lifers that investigations continue even when developments cannot yet be made public.
Then, a possible new lead emerges in one of America's most notorious unsolved cases: the 1982 Chicago Tylenol Murders. Seven people died after taking cyanide-laced capsules, forever changing consumer packaging. Now, investigators are examining information concerning a man found dead in an Idaho church in 1982 and his possible connection to the killings. The case remains unsolved.
Woody also covers a Carnival cruise passenger reported overboard during a family anniversary trip and a Minnesota driver accused of fatally striking a pedestrian before proceeding through a McDonald's drive-thru.
In Family Matters, a Kentucky couple faces disturbing allegations of prolonged child abuse. Then, in F'd Up Professionals, a Detroit family discovers the woman prepared for their mother's funeral isn't their mother—and learns a devastating cremation mix-up may have occurred.
Woody closes with a reminder to never give up, never surrender, and keep the tips coming.
True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Chicago Tylenol Murders, 1982 Tylenol poisonings, Mathew Francis Betkouski, Unknown Wanderer, James Lewis, cyanide poisoning, Alex Ray Kisch, Minnesota hit and run, Kyle Reynolds, Phyllis Culp, Kimberly Moore, Detroit funeral home, Family Matters, F'd Up Professionals, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Justice for Hailey, Hailey Johnson
#JusticeForHailey and #JusticeForMadison updates
A possible new lead in the 1982 Tylenol Murders
Identification of the Unknown Wanderer
James Lewis and the original Tylenol investigation
Carnival Panorama passenger reported overboard
Minnesota fatal hit-and-run and McDonald's drive-thru
Kentucky child-abuse allegations
Detroit funeral home and cremation mix-up

The central development is the identification of Dr. Mathew Francis Betkouski, formerly known as Boise's Unknown Wanderer. Idaho investigators have shared information suggesting a possible connection to the Chicago Tylenol Murders, but Betkouski has not been officially named a suspect, and the seven killings remain unsolved.

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Cyndi Overton takes over True Crime Time For with a story she intended to cover quickly—but couldn't. On September 28, 1953, six-year-old Robert “Bobby” Greenlease Jr. was taken from his Kansas City school by a woman claiming his mother had suffered a heart attack. Bonnie Heady and Carl Hall demanded $600,000 for Bobby's return, even though they had already killed him. The FBI investigation ended with Bobby's body recovered, Hall and Heady executed less than three months later, and more than half of the ransom money never recovered. Pasted text The FBI's records confirm the names and major details of Cyndi's account. FBI
Then it's Family Matters. In Arizona, Gary Crawford receives life plus 21 years for murdering his 91-year-old stepfather and attempting to murder his mother. In Missouri, Mariah Thomas is sentenced to 13 years after pleading guilty to child endangerment resulting in the death of her one-month-old daughter, whom she told investigators she accidentally placed in an oven instead of a crib. Pasted text Pasted text Us
Cyndi also covers the extraordinary Florida case against plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski, convicted of murdering attorney Steven Cozzi despite Cozzi's body never being recovered, along with a Colorado woman accused of killing and dismembering her husband. Pasted text Pasted text
Later, an armed Airbnb break-in ends with one alleged intruder shot by the renter; Florida MRI technician Gabriel Cruz is accused of sexually assaulting a sedated patient; and Stephen Gress pleads guilty to first-degree murder in the brutal death of 16-year-old Miranda Corsett. Pasted text Cruz has been charged, and the allegation remains pending. NBC Miami
Cyndi closes with #JusticeForHailey, sending love to Hailey Johnson's mother, Barbara, and asking Lifers to continue supporting her fight for answers. Pasted text

True Crime Time For, Cyndi Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Bobby Greenlease, Robert Greenlease Jr, Bonnie Heady, Carl Hall, Greenlease kidnapping, Steven Cozzi, Tomasz Kosowski, Gary Crawford, Mariah Thomas, Za'Riah Thomas, Gabriel Cruz, Miranda Corsett, Stephen Gress, Family Matters, Justice for Hailey, Hailey Johnson, Barbara Johnson, true crime
Bobby Greenlease kidnapping and murder
Bonnie Heady and Carl Hall
$600,000 ransom and missing money
Gary Crawford family murder case
Steven Cozzi murder without a recovered body
Tomasz Kosowski conviction
Mariah Thomas and the death of infant Za'Riah
Colorado dismemberment case
Florida Airbnb self-defense investigation
Gabriel Cruz MRI sexual-battery allegation
Stephen Gress and Miranda Corsett
#JusticeForHailey
The centerpiece of Episode 288 is clearly Bobby Greenlease. Cyndi begins with what was supposed to be a quick “On This Day” story and ends up telling the full FBI account—from Bobby walking out of school holding his kidnapper's hand through the executions of Hall and Heady. Pasted text
A couple of transcript spellings are worth correcting before publication: Bonnie Heady, Carl Austin Hall, Robert Cosgrove Greenlease Jr., Steven Cozzi, Tomasz Kosowski, and Gabriel Cruz. The Missouri infant's name is reported as Za'Riah Mae. 

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton opens with #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie, thanking listeners for the tips coming in following the newly announced reward and urging anyone with firsthand information to contact investigators. Pasted text
On this day in 2022, 19-year-old Tamir Jones was shot and killed outside his Philadelphia home. Woody follows the case beyond the original unsolved murder and explains how investigators eventually connected suspects to both Tamir's killing and another deadly shooting. Pasted text
Then, a horrifying developing case out of Pennsylvania: Dr. Idris Evans, a 46-year-old pediatric critical-care physician at UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, was fatally stabbed after an intruder allegedly entered his home and attacked Evans and his wife while they slept. Their two children escaped unharmed. Elijah Hemingway, 32, has been charged with criminal homicide, aggravated assault, burglary and criminal trespass. CBS News
Woody also travels through true-crime history with Machine Gun Kelly, the Johnny Lewis case, the Charles Sherman Ross kidnapping, the Alabama cell-phone murders, mob boss Albert Anastasia, the Indiana State Prison escape and the Phil Spector murder trial. Pasted text
In Worldwide Crime, Woody covers a deadly stabbing attack at a monastery in Poland before turning to Tennessee death row inmate Christa Pike, who is scheduled for execution September 30 for the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer. Pike's attorneys have sought clemency and raised objections concerning the execution protocol; Tennessee currently has her execution scheduled for 10 a.m. CDT at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution. Pasted text Tennessee State Government
Woody closes with a look at recent and upcoming executions around the country and his thoughts on capital punishment. Pasted text
True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Madison Renee Allen, Stephanie Hevia, Thomas Morris, Tamir Jones, Idris Evans, Elijah Hemingway, Christa Pike, Colleen Slemmer, Tennessee death row, Machine Gun Kelly, Johnny Lewis, Albert Anastasia, Phil Spector, death penalty, capital punishment, true crime

#JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie
New tips following the reward announcement
Tamir Jones murder investigation
Murder of Dr. Idris Evans
Elijah Hemingway charges
Machine Gun Kelly
Johnny Lewis and Catherine Davis
Albert Anastasia and Murder Inc.
Phil Spector
Poland monastery stabbing
Christa Pike and Colleen Slemmer
Upcoming U.S. executions
Death penalty and capital punishment

The Pittsburgh case is still developing. Police say Elijah Hemingway is accused of entering the Evans home and attacking Dr. Idris Evans and his wife while they slept; Hemingway has been charged, not convicted. WPXI
And one important correction from the transcript: the Tennessee death-row inmate's name is Christa Gail Pike, and her victim was Colleen Slemmer. Tennessee officially lists Pike's execution for September 30, 2026. 

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Woody Overton opens with an important #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie update: the West Feliciana Parish Sheriff’s Office and Capital Region Crime Stoppers are offering a reward for information that could help resolve the disappearances of Madison Allen and Stephanie Hevia. The reward is temporarily increased to $10,000, and tipsters can remain anonymous. Pasted text WBRZ independently confirms the reward announcement and that Thomas Morris remains a person of interest after his July arrest on unrelated kidnapping allegations. WBRZ
Woody also marks the National Day of Remembrance for Murder Victims before revisiting several crimes from September 25, including the Woodman “Ninja Murders,” the 1953 FBI shootout with John Elgin Johnson, and the 1987 Elkland massacre. Pasted text
Then comes long-awaited news in the disappearance of Jason Landry, the Texas State University student who vanished after crashing his car in December 2020. Nearly six years later, remains discovered approximately five miles from the crash site have been identified as Jason. Woody reflects on what finally bringing him home means to his family—and why families searching for Madison, Stephanie and other missing loved ones can never give up. Pasted text
There’s also a much lighter Dum Dum in the Court involving bank robbers who believed lemon juice would make their faces invisible to surveillance cameras, followed by a Florida hidden-camera investigation involving Shawn Michael Krause. Pasted text
Finally, Woody turns to the deaths of two University of Mississippi students and growing concern surrounding kratom. Packaged kratom was found during both death investigations, but authorities have emphasized that the deaths are separate and have not determined that kratom caused either death; toxicology results remain pending. https://www.actionnews5.com Woody closes with a warning about the risks of easily accessible substances with opioid-like effects. Pasted text

True Crime Time For, Woody Overton, Real Life Real Crime, Justice for Madison, Justice for Stephanie, Madison Allen, Stephanie Hevia, Thomas Morris, Brian Spillman, West Feliciana Parish, Capital Region Crime Stoppers, Jason Landry, Texas State University, National Day of Remembrance for Murder Victims, Woodman murders, Ninja murders, James Schnick, Elkland massacre, Dunning Kruger effect, kratom, Ole Miss, University of Mississippi, missing persons, true crime
$10,000 #JusticeForMadison and #JusticeForStephanie reward
Anonymous Crime Stoppers tips
National Day of Remembrance for Murder Victims
Woodman/Ninja Murders
Elkland massacre
Jason Landry’s remains identified
Why missing-person investigations should never be abandoned
Lemon-juice bank robbers and the Dunning-Kruger effect
Shawn Michael Krause hidden-camera investigation
Two University of Mississippi student deaths
Kratom and public-safety concerns
Importance of separating confirmed findings from speculation
Takeaways
The biggest current developments are the $10,000 reward in the Madison and Stephanie investigation and the identification of Jason Landry after almost six years. In the Ole Miss story, it is especially important that the show notes not say kratom killed the students. Packaged kratom was recovered during both investigations, but as of September 24, toxicology results were still pending and authorities had not established either cause of death or a connection between the two deaths.

Our Sponsors:
* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.com
* Check out Progressive: https://www.progressive.com

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy